DISQUS

The Disqus Blog: Regarding The Recent Spam

  • Jeff Tunnell · 10 months ago
    I'm with Vinny, here. I have absolutely loved using Disqus since I installed it, but if you can't figure out how to do something about the complement spam, I am going to go back to WP with Akismet protection. Don't believe the BS from the people posting below that it is a difficult line. They are probably complement spammers themselves.

    I don't care if I get those complements like "Great post, I'm adding you to my RSS" even from my regular readers. Watch for phrases like that, see if users are posting on more than one site in a day, watch to see if they are posting the same phrases on several blogs, give us better flagging tools that add up across the system to weed them out. Give us variable sign up that allow us as site owners to put stricter controls on how much info a comment needs before we allow it on our site. Allow us to whitelist members into our community. Allow us to only allow people to sign up via Facebook Connect, Google Friend Connect or some other trusted source to make sure these people are real. Or make Disqus the trusted source, but have a stricter sign up method that proves their identity. Don't allow a member to post a link until they have proven themselves with <n> number of real posts, i.e. figure out why they are posting and take away the incentive.

    The email controls are nice, but not if I am getting 20 or so complement spams in one setting. I know it won't be easy, but I am sure you guys can figure it out. I am looking forward to your solution because the future of your business depends upon you figuring out how to deal with this threat.
  • Randy · 10 months ago
    I was wondering ... it was starting to irritate me. Thanks for addressing the issue.
  • Randy · 10 months ago
    Ok ... it only seems to be getting worse.
  • WasatchGirl · 10 months ago
    Thank you.
  • sfoskett · 10 months ago
    Thanks for the quick response and tweak, Giannii!

    There's a slippery slope between comments and comment spam, but intent is what matters. If someone leaves a comment saying "I love your site and will add it to my rss feed", they might be actual fans, or they might be SEO page rank harvesters, looking to coast along on your hard-earned status. It's up to all of us to decide which bin to put them in!

    I've noticed that many of these comments are verbatim copies of each other, though, and I'll sometimes get the same comment from the same "person" on multiple posts. Now that's definitely spam!
  • Chris Charabaruk · 10 months ago
    Excellent!
  • Chris Charabaruk · 10 months ago
    Excellent!
  • Chris Charabaruk · 10 months ago
    Excellent!
  • Randy · 10 months ago
    I was wondering ... it was starting to irritate me. Thanks for addressing the issue.
  • sfoskett · 10 months ago
    Thanks for the quick response and tweak, Giannii!

    There's a slippery slope between comments and comment spam, but intent is what matters. If someone leaves a comment saying "I love your site and will add it to my rss feed", they might be actual fans, or they might be SEO page rank harvesters, looking to coast along on your hard-earned status. It's up to all of us to decide which bin to put them in!

    I've noticed that many of these comments are verbatim copies of each other, though, and I'll sometimes get the same comment from the same "person" on multiple posts. Now that's definitely spam!
  • WasatchGirl · 10 months ago
    Thank you.
  • Dries · 10 months ago
    Have you looked into adding Mollom support to Disqus?
  • Dries · 10 months ago
    Have you looked into adding Mollom support to Disqus?
  • Dries · 10 months ago
    Have you looked into adding Mollom support to Disqus?
  • Giannii · 10 months ago
    I will definitely check it out and thanks for the suggestion.

    =)

    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    help@disqus.com
  • timmillwood · 9 months ago
    Would be great to see Mollom as part of Disqus.
  • spamboy · 10 months ago
    Help help
    this guy is stealing our personal domain data and needs to be stopped

    Atriks and Brian Haberstroh were major spammers (google them)
    The good news is his email business failed but his distributed network of PC’s which is under his other company www.greenhorse .com is still active
    Essentially Mr. Haberstroh has gone postal
    Here is the story
    First you must give credit to Atriks partner James Rascoe of Dunbarton NH he is the inventor of www.greenhorse.com and code writer extraordinaire his talents are routinely put to use in scraping corporate data from websites and bypassing spam filters. And has gone to great lengths to hide his association with Mr. Haberstroh although he owns 49% of Atriks.
    The facts are as follows
    In the process of sending spam for other companies Atriks would steal part of their clients data file which they would then use the file they created to send spam with the “tickerbar” software embedded in it, the unsuspecting recipient would then open and unknowingly download the “tickerbar” software which would then give Atriks the ability to control the user’s PC.
    As of 2008 they had aprox 5000 PC’s with the “tickerbar” software installed aprox half of which are unaware it is running on their system and the naïve users that knowingly downloaded the software do not receive any compensation
    Mr. Haberstroh through his other company www.domaincow.com convinced VeriSign the he is running DNS servers and therefore needs the “zone transfer file” this file identifies every .com and .net domain name registered.
    Upon receipt of the file he is able to select out every new .com and .net domain registered on a daily basis
    With a file of all new domain registrations in hand he then feeds the file into the www.greenhorse.com system the 5000 PC’s the PC’s then query the “whois” lookup on websites controlled by VeriSign
    www.whois.net

    Because the queries are coming from 5000 different IP addresses he is able to bypass basic security
    And obtain all of the “whois “ information (postal, telephone, email)
    The email addresses are sold to spam operations and the postal and telephone numbers are
    Provided to list brokers www.marketforcecorporation.com and www.infinite-media.com who then sell it to many large reputable corporations who are unaware of the source of the data filling our mailboxes with postal junk
    The bottom line is VeriSign is aware of Mr. Haberstroh and what he is doing and despite the agreement Mr. Haberstroh signed with VeriSign to receive the “zone transfer file” which specifically restricts any mass electronic queries of the “whois “ data base and the use of the data for marketing purposes. VeriSign chose not to suspend Mr. Haberstroh's access to the “zone transfer file” thereby permitting the wholesale theft of personal information.
    You may respond to this email with any questions
    Regards
  • Giannii · 10 months ago
    I will definitely check it out and thanks for the suggestion.

    =)

    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    giannii@disqus.com
  • Randy · 10 months ago
    Ok ... it only seems to be getting worse.
  • Randy · 10 months ago
    Ok ... it only seems to be getting worse.
  • Didofan1991 · 10 months ago
    I actually get e-mail "This message has been flagged as spam." about my OWN comments. Not the most usefull thing ^^
  • Didofan1991 · 10 months ago
    I actually get e-mail "This message has been flagged as spam." about my OWN comments. Not the most usefull thing ^^
  • Didofan1991 · 10 months ago
    I actually get e-mail "This message has been flagged as spam." about my OWN comments. Not the most usefull thing ^^
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The problem is that a lot of these users are just parading around and hitting multiple sites even with their Disqus logins. What Disqus needs is a way to flag users for review by Disqus this way if someone else catches a spammer, their comments move into the spam queue across the board. This is one benefit made possible by the fact that Disqus is cross-site.

    I'm seriously considering moving back to Wordpress' default comments simply because Disqus' comment spam feature is so anemic. It doesn't catch a lot and doesn't allow features you would expect from a networked system.
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The problem is that a lot of these users are just parading around and hitting multiple sites even with their Disqus logins. What Disqus needs is a way to flag users for review by Disqus this way if someone else catches a spammer, their comments move into the spam queue across the board. This is one benefit made possible by the fact that Disqus is cross-site.

    I'm seriously considering moving back to Wordpress' default comments simply because Disqus' comment spam feature is so anemic. It doesn't catch a lot and doesn't allow features you would expect from a networked system.
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The problem is that a lot of these users are just parading around and hitting multiple sites even with their Disqus logins. What Disqus needs is a way to flag users for review by Disqus this way if someone else catches a spammer, their comments move into the spam queue across the board. This is one benefit made possible by the fact that Disqus is cross-site.

    I'm seriously considering moving back to Wordpress' default comments simply because Disqus' comment spam feature is so anemic. It doesn't catch a lot and doesn't allow features you would expect from a networked system.
  • Jeff Tunnell · 10 months ago
    I'm with Vinny, here. I have absolutely loved using Disqus since I installed it, but if you can't figure out how to do something about the complement spam, I am going to go back to WP with Akismet protection. Don't believe the BS from the people posting below that it is a difficult line. They are probably complement spammers themselves.

    I don't care if I get those complements like "Great post, I'm adding you to my RSS" even from my regular readers. Watch for phrases like that, see if users are posting on more than one site in a day, watch to see if they are posting the same phrases on several blogs, give us better flagging tools that add up across the system to weed them out. Give us variable sign up that allow us as site owners to put stricter controls on how much info a comment needs before we allow it on our site. Allow us to whitelist members into our community. Allow us to only allow people to sign up via Facebook Connect, Google Friend Connect or some other trusted source to make sure these people are real. Or make Disqus the trusted source, but have a stricter sign up method that proves their identity. Don't allow a member to post a link until they have proven themselves with <n> number of real posts, i.e. figure out why they are posting and take away the incentive.

    The email controls are nice, but not if I am getting 20 or so complement spams in one setting. I know it won't be easy, but I am sure you guys can figure it out. I am looking forward to your solution because the future of your business depends upon you figuring out how to deal with this threat.
  • Kyle Brady · 10 months ago
    I didn't see any at that point, but I agree with Randy.

    It seems to be getting worse. It's not relevant, but it's usually a comment like "nice post good job"... no links, no hidden message or promotion...

    But it's still SPAM.

    --Kyle
  • Kyle Brady · 10 months ago
    I didn't see any at that point, but I agree with Randy.

    It seems to be getting worse. It's not relevant, but it's usually a comment like "nice post good job"... no links, no hidden message or promotion...

    But it's still SPAM.

    --Kyle
  • Record-Eagle Webmaster · 10 months ago
    Count me in as someone who might not continue using Disqus if the spam filtering isn't beefed up. I'm being plauged by a compliment spammer called "sex toys" and even when I block this user, their comments still get through. C'mon!
  • Record-Eagle Webmaster · 10 months ago
    Count me in as someone who might not continue using Disqus if the spam filtering isn't beefed up. I'm being plauged by a compliment spammer called "sex toys" and even when I block this user, their comments still get through. C'mon!
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The worst part of it is that these comment spammers are using registered "legit" Disqus accounts across multiple blogs and spamming the hell out of Disqus. If I flag a user, and you flag a user and someone else flags a user, then all of their respective comments should be removed as spam pending moderator approval. End of story.

    I've removed Disqus until this gets figured out and it really annoys me because there are so many reasons to like it, but I don't want my site plagued with spam, particularly spam that Akismet catches in one second.
  • Record-Eagle Webmaster · 10 months ago
    Count me in as someone who might not continue using Disqus if the spam filtering isn't beefed up. I'm being plauged by a compliment spammer called "sex toys" and even when I block this user, their comments still get through. C'mon!
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The worst part of it is that these comment spammers are using registered "legit" Disqus accounts across multiple blogs and spamming the hell out of Disqus. If I flag a user, and you flag a user and someone else flags a user, then all of their respective comments should be removed as spam pending moderator approval. End of story.

    I've removed Disqus until this gets figured out and it really annoys me because there are so many reasons to like it, but I don't want my site plagued with spam, particularly spam that Akismet catches in one second.
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The worst part of it is that these comment spammers are using registered "legit" Disqus accounts across multiple blogs and spamming the hell out of Disqus. If I flag a user, and you flag a user and someone else flags a user, then all of their respective comments should be removed as spam pending moderator approval. End of story.

    I've removed Disqus until this gets figured out and it really annoys me because there are so many reasons to like it, but I don't want my site plagued with spam, particularly spam that Akismet catches in one second.
  • Record-Eagle Webmaster · 10 months ago
    Count me in as someone who might not continue using Disqus if the spam filtering isn't beefed up. I'm being plauged by a compliment spammer called "sex toys" and even when I block this user, their comments still get through. C'mon!
  • Rob Spectre · 10 months ago
    Thanks Giannii - you guys have been really proactive in your outreach over this issue.

    That kind of transparency in a hosted service that is free is really excellent. Many thanks.
  • Vinny · 10 months ago
    The worst part of it is that these comment spammers are using registered "legit" Disqus accounts across multiple blogs and spamming the hell out of Disqus. If I flag a user, and you flag a user and someone else flags a user, then all of their respective comments should be removed as spam pending moderator approval. End of story.

    I've removed Disqus until this gets figured out and it really annoys me because there are so many reasons to like it, but I don't want my site plagued with spam, particularly spam that Akismet catches in one second.
  • Zoli Erdos · 10 months ago
    Evan MARK SPAM manually does not work for me:

    - the spam comment is not displayed under the blog post - that's good
    - but it is still listed in the "recent comments" widget in my sidebar, which is really, really bad

    I'm also getting close to removing DISQUS :-(
  • Giannii · 10 months ago
    Zoli,

    The recent comments widget refreshes every 15 minutes and that spam
    comment was most likely cached before you hit mark as spam. Which
    comment is it? If it is still lurking I will look into it.

    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    giannii@disqus.com
  • Giannii · 10 months ago
    Zoli,

    The recent comments widget refreshes every 15 minutes and that spam
    comment was most likely cached before you hit mark as spam. Which
    comment is it? If it is still lurking I will look into it.

    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    giannii@disqus.com
  • Zoli Erdos · 10 months ago
    Giannii,

    It's more then just the widget, it's WP not seeing what DISQUS marked as SPAM. Sent you email with details.
  • Zoli Erdos · 10 months ago
    Giannii,

    It's more then just the widget, it's WP not seeing what DISQUS marked as SPAM. Sent you email with details.
  • Rosie57 · 10 months ago
    Hi, I'm new here and I feel very good to know that there are spam filters being put in place. Also from what I have seen and read so far I know I'm going to like here. I'm in the right place.
  • Rosie57 · 10 months ago
    Hi, I'm new here and I feel very good to know that there are spam filters being put in place. Also from what I have seen and read so far I know I'm going to like here. I'm in the right place.
  • Rosie57 · 10 months ago
    Hi, I'm new here and I feel very good to know that there are spam filters being put in place. Also from what I have seen and read so far I know I'm going to like here. I'm in the right place.
  • MarbleHost · 10 months ago
    Divisive Cotton I have to agree with what you're saying. This wasn't against pligg at all. Sure they used pligg as a platform but I don't think it' was against pligg.

    <a href="http://www.marblehost.com rel="nofollow">Marble Host
  • MarbleHost · 10 months ago
    Divisive Cotton I have to agree with what you're saying. This wasn't against pligg at all. Sure they used pligg as a platform but I don't think it' was against pligg.

    <a href="http://www.marblehost.com rel="nofollow">Marble Host
  • MarbleHost · 10 months ago
    Divisive Cotton I have to agree with what you're saying. This wasn't against pligg at all. Sure they used pligg as a platform but I don't think it' was against pligg.

    Marble Host
  • garjani · 9 months ago
    Raivo Pommer
    raimo1@hot.ee

    EZB krise

    "Zu spät, zu zögerlich"

    Der DGB ging die EZB dagegen scharf an. "Sie reagiert zu spät und zu zögerlich auf die historische Wirtschaftskrise", sagte der Chefvolkswirt der Deutschen Gewerkschaftsbundes (DGB), Dierk Hirschel.




    "Sie hätte sich ein Beispiel an den angelsächsischen Banken nehmen und die Zinsen schnell und drastisch senken sollen." In den USA liegt der Leitzins nahe null Prozent.

    Vor der EZB hatte am Mittag bereits die Bank von England ihren Leitzins auf das historische Tief von 0,5 Prozent gekappt und den Ankauf von Staatsanleihen angekündigt um zusätzlich Milliarden in die Wirtschaft zu pumpen.
  • garjani · 9 months ago
    Raivo Pommer
    raimo1@hot.ee

    EZB krise

    "Zu spät, zu zögerlich"

    Der DGB ging die EZB dagegen scharf an. "Sie reagiert zu spät und zu zögerlich auf die historische Wirtschaftskrise", sagte der Chefvolkswirt der Deutschen Gewerkschaftsbundes (DGB), Dierk Hirschel.




    "Sie hätte sich ein Beispiel an den angelsächsischen Banken nehmen und die Zinsen schnell und drastisch senken sollen." In den USA liegt der Leitzins nahe null Prozent.

    Vor der EZB hatte am Mittag bereits die Bank von England ihren Leitzins auf das historische Tief von 0,5 Prozent gekappt und den Ankauf von Staatsanleihen angekündigt um zusätzlich Milliarden in die Wirtschaft zu pumpen.
  • Facebook User · 9 months ago
    test #giannii
  • Promotional · 9 months ago
    Nice Topic. I just subscribe to your blog for future update.

    Can i link this post to my blog and copy a snippet?

    God bless and good luck!
  • timmillwood · 9 months ago
    Would be great to see Mollom as part of Disqus.
  • timmillwood · 9 months ago
    Would be great to see Mollom as part of Disqus.
  • krishnamoorthy · 8 months ago
    Today I am getting scores of spam. Tired of marking everything as spam :)
  • Giannii · 8 months ago
    Could you send me a couple of those full email notifications? I can take a
    look for you.
    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    help@disqus.com
    http://twitter.com/giannii
  • krishnamoorthy · 8 months ago
    Today I am getting scores of spam. Tired of marking everything as spam :)
  • Giannii · 8 months ago
    Could you send me a couple of those full email notifications? I can take a
    look for you.
    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    giannii@disqus.com
    http://twitter.com/giannii
  • tnomeralc web design toys · 7 months ago
    actually guys it depends..it depends to the administrator who accept the spamming message or to allow to help others..so for me it deference purpose guys..regards
  • tnomeralc web design toys · 7 months ago
    actually guys it depends..it depends to the administrator who accept the spamming message or to allow to help others..so for me it deference purpose guys..regards
  • tnomeralc web design toys · 7 months ago
    actually guys it depends..it depends to the administrator who accept the spamming message or to allow to help others..so for me it deference purpose guys..regards
  • wallace530 · 7 months ago
    great post sir..
    thanks for sharing. really helped a lot here.
    --------------------------------------------------
    Ugg Boots | Uggs
  • Zoli Erdos · 10 months ago
    Evan "MARK SPAM" manually does not work for me:

    - the spam comment is not displayed under the blog post - that's good
    - but it is still listed in the "recent comments" widget in my sidebar, which is really, really bad

    I'm also getting close to removing DISQUS :-(
  • Giannii · 10 months ago
    Zoli,

    The recent comments widget refreshes every 15 minutes and that spam
    comment was most likely cached before you hit mark as spam. Which
    comment is it? If it is still lurking I will look into it.

    Giannii
    DISQUS
    Community Manager
    help@disqus.com
  • Zoli Erdos · 10 months ago
    Giannii,

    It's more then just the widget, it's WP not seeing what DISQUS marked as SPAM. Sent you email with details.