DISQUS

Community Page on DISQUS

what is this?

DISQUS Blog

The official Disqus forum. This is the place to receive beta support and offer suggestions.
« Back
Author

How do I import comments?

Started by randyaa · 5 months ago

This is exactly what I've been looking for but I can't risk losing existing comments. I tried the 'mixed' approach (Replace all entries with no comments) but I don't like the unorganized feel it gives my blog.

'Replace comments on all posts' scares me since I don't know if its removing the existing comments or just forgetting they exist and leaving the database alone.

Also I don't see anyway to export the comments in disqus so i can import them into wordpress later if I feel like it, is there a way to do this?

PS: please give us search, I'm sure my questions have already been asked but i have no idea how to tell.

46 comments

  • moserw

    1 month ago

    Hmmm. Any updates on how to import comments into Disqus? I still got comments on my old default WP that have not been integrated into Disqus. I recently changed the theme and all those old comments disappeared. Of course I still see them in my admin panel, but Disqus has replaced all commenting on my blog so the old comments cannot be found anymore on my blog. I am wondering how best to import them under Disqus. This topic aside Disqus Rocks! Keep it up guys.
    reply
  • jarek91

    1 month ago

    Yeah, I'm looking for an update to WP comment import status as well. Maybe if we add a few more posts in this topic we can get Daniel to drop us a bone.
    reply
  • blowmage

    1 month ago

    Daniel Ha, any update on this?
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    1 month ago

    Yes, it will be a part of our next release.
    reply
  • blowmage

    1 month ago

    Excellent. How long until the next release?
    reply
  • jarek91

    1 month ago

    He probably won't say. He's said many times that they don't like to give ETAs because schedules can slip. So if he doesn't commit, they're never late ^_^;;

    But it would be nice to get a ballpark of whether we're looking at days, weeks, or months.
    reply
  • blowmage

    1 month ago

    He _did_ say this would be available in June. I agree a ballpark answer would be nice. Weeks or months?
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    1 month ago

    Weeks.

    I did say June but I was wrong. I don't mind being wrong but I don't like to give bad ETAs to people.

    It's not awaiting development. It's just part of something bigger now. Hang on tight.
    reply
  • Jason A Clark

    1 month ago

    Well see, now we're all excited again!
    reply
  • Jonathan

    1 month ago

    It won't hurt for me to go ahead and comment-vote for a ballpark estimate. june didn't so much pan out...
    reply
  • Jason A Clark

    2 months ago

    Pop Critics is definitely thinking of working Disqus into our new site design so we're incredibly happy to hear that the Wordpress import feature seems imminent. We too have a LOT of comments that we want to be able to bring into the new design. So far everything we've seen from Disqus has been impressive.
    reply
  • Mike Olbinski

    2 months ago

    I'm curious why this reply is above the one below, which is from 3 weeks ago?

    How does that work?
    reply
  • Jason A Clark

    2 months ago

    I was wondering the same thing.
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    2 months ago

    There are various sort options for Disqus. It's likely that the score
    on the post is higher than the one below.
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    5 months ago

    1) "Replace comments on all posts" leaves the database alone. It just forgets it exists, but your data is intact.

    2) Yes, you can Export comments under Integration Settings.

    3) Still no search, but it's being worked on.

    4) We hear you about importing into Disqus. It's something that is still planned.

    Thanks!
    reply
  • randyaa

    5 months ago

    1) excellent I'll start using it now then!

    2) perfect, I assume there are plans for importing these same exported files at some point?

    3) Yep I saw somewhere else that you're working on it, that is very good news as it's definitely something big that's missing.

    4) Awesome! Do you know what sort of format will be allowed or will you be able to magically import directly from your blog (wordpress for example) ?

    I'm very new here but I'm already very impressed with both the level of responsiveness as well as the system itself.
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    5 months ago

    Great!
    reply
  • ATLChris

    3 months ago

    Any idea when we might see this functionality come to Disqus? I use wordpress, and I gave up about 100 comments on my blog when I switched to Disqus. I would love to get them imported into the new system.
    reply
  • Sherman

    5 months ago

    Great Service! Thanks!

    My question is related: Does anyone know how to export comments from a TypePad blog for import into Disqus?
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    5 months ago

    You can export from Disqus by going to http://disqus.com/migrate

    At the moment, importing into Disqus is not fully supported. Once we sort
    out the kinks, we'll update you. Thanks!
    reply
  • Sherman

    5 months ago

    Awesome. I have, like, 6000 typepad blogs, so if you need someone to test or anything you know where to find me.
    reply
  • Daehee Park

    3 months ago

    The import feature (directly from the Wordpress admin interface) was one of the selling points of Intense Debate, but I still decided on Disqus with the hope of seeing this feature soon!
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    3 months ago

    It will most definitely show up soon. Cheers!
    reply
  • felix

    3 months ago

    I'd just like to throw my wish in for importing from wordpress. :)
    reply
  • Stewart Marshall

    3 months ago

    Importing would be great - I use Movable Type and despite being only a lowly level of geekish, managed to set up Disqus wihout any problems - great job on making that easy!

    I don't have a huge number of comments but it sure would be nice to import them to disqus - so I would like to add my encouragement to add this feature!
    reply
  • haraldf

    1 month ago

    So do I! Movable Type 3.35 in my case. Thanks ...
    reply
  • Kate Foy

    3 months ago

    I'm a WordPress self-hosted blogger and like a lot of others here, I await the arrival of an import comments function into Disqus. Until then I keep my plug-in deactivated. I care too much about the comments I have to 'lose' them.

    Great that Seesmic was integrated yesterday. I switched everything back on this morning hoping you'd provided the import functionality as well. Nope. Deactivated again.

    Any idea when it's coming ... ETA or something? Love the Disqus concept and look BTW!
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    3 months ago

    Hi Dramagirl,

    We don't have a definite ETA, but it's a priority. We're looking at June.
    reply
  • Jonathan

    2 months ago

    oh god oh god oh god i can't wait to be able to import from Wordpress. it's june... any further news on ETA?
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    2 months ago

    June has 30 days. :)

    Further news: it's coming along.
    reply
  • Jonathan

    2 months ago

    I read another blog post (or maybe a comment) recently that maintained that using Disqus might diminish the SEO-friendliness of your UGC, since the comments are hosted somewhere else and will not add "freshness" to a post that improve its page rank.

    I'll hopefully be using Disqus with Wordpress once the import functionality gets developed. Is the above assertion true or false?
    reply
  • Riaz

    1 month ago

    <chuckles> 6 days of those 30 left - we still looking at June or will it slip to July?
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    1 month ago

    We don't like giving ETAs because they slip. It's being worked on, but not solely. There are priorities ahead of this feature and I do appreciate the patience.
    reply
  • gluca

    1 month ago

    I'm a Haloscan user (please don't laugh :), it can export in xml format.
    let us know! :)
    reply
  • avh4

    1 month ago

    +1 for an API to import comments
    reply
  • Jordan Willms

    1 month ago

    +1 vote for import comments

    J, http://www.sumolabs.com
    reply
  • nasirjumani

    2 weeks ago

    I too need the import into wp function.....will it be available in august?
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    2 weeks ago

    Yes.
    reply
  • nasirjumani

    2 weeks ago

    Thanks for answering....waiting for the update! :)
    reply
  • jmb

    6 days ago

    I'm really impressed with this tool. It took me less than half an hour to get this integrated into a Drupal blog using Rob Loach's module. A mechanism to import comments into Disqus would be very handy, though.

    I'm backing up Disqus comments using the RSS feed, which is a tip I picked up from someone else, but I'm not too worried about migration paths, as this looks like a really great service. (Gravatar must be a bit worried, though.)
    reply
  • hypermark

    3 months ago

    So just to make sure that I understand. I am a TypePad blogger. I have legacy posts that generate a fair bit of traffic/comments so in a perfect world would apply to all posts but can't risk losing my legacy comments. It's not enough for them to be sitting in a DB invisible to visitors and wait until you have some import function. Do you have a workaround that accomplishes my goals or is best answer to just apply to new posts?

    Thanks in advance.

    Mark
    reply
  • kten

    2 months ago

    I cannot wait for the import feature !!!
    hurry up guys!! :)
    I was using ID for some time, but the darn thign never let me import / export mu comments...I lost a lot of comments because of ID!
    Now i am on to Disqus..hope it likes me! :)
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    2 months ago

    We're working hard on it. :)
    reply
  • baratunde aka jack turner

    1 month ago

    glad to hear it.

    i just installed disqus at www.jackandjillpolitics.com

    we're a pretty big political blog, and i'm excited to see how our folks react to the new system.
    reply
  • Daniel Ha

    1 month ago

    Very cool. I noticed that you're not getting the proper comments link on the main page.

    The fix is here: http://disqus.com/help/#faq-17

    Let me know if you need anything at all: daniel@disqus.com
    reply
  • Haggis

    1 month ago

    So.. maybe a Happy July 4th present from the devs? I just added the plugin to my Wordpress blog(s) and love it! http://www.dailyhaggis.com/

    I chose the "Only entries with no comments" option until the import feature is enabled. Looking forward to it.

    GREAT job on this service, by the way. Much needed.
    reply

Add New Comment

Returning? Login